Why Are Creators Looking for Sellfy Alternatives?
While Sellfy is a solid all-in-one platform, many creators are exploring alternatives. Here's why:
High Monthly Costs
Sellfy starts at $29/month but quickly jumps to $79-159/month as you grow. With revenue caps on each tier, you're forced to upgrade or pay overage fees.
Premium plan at $159/month = $1,908/year just for the platform
Revenue Caps & Overage Fees
Sellfy's Starter plan caps at $10K/year, Business at $50K, and Premium at $200K. Exceed your cap and you'll face 2% overage fees on additional revenue.
Hitting $15K on Starter? That's $100 extra in overage fees
Paying for Features You Don't Need
Sellfy bundles print-on-demand, email marketing, and physical products. If you only sell digital downloads, you're paying for features you'll never use.
Digital-only creators can find leaner, cheaper solutions
No Direct Payment Control
Sellfy processes payments through their system. With platforms like PengDrop, payments go directly to YOUR Stripe account - you control your money.
Direct Stripe = instant access to your funds
How Much Could You Save?
Compare Sellfy's tiered pricing vs PengDrop's flat $20/month (both 0% fees):
| Your Annual Revenue | Sellfy Plan Needed | PengDrop Pro | Your Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Up to $10K/year | $29/month (Starter) | $20/month | $9/month ($108/year) |
| Up to $50K/year | $79/month (Business) | $20/month | $59/month ($708/year) |
| Up to $200K/year | $159/month (Premium) | $20/month | $139/month ($1,668/year) |
| Over $200K/year | $159/month + 2% overage | $20/month | $139+/month |
* Both platforms have 0% transaction fees. Sellfy has revenue caps that force upgrades.
Payment processing fees (Stripe ~2.9% + 30¢) apply to all platforms.
PengDrop: The Best Sellfy Alternative for Digital Products
0% platform fees at a fraction of Sellfy's cost - perfect for digital creators
Why PengDrop Beats Sellfy
- Lower monthly cost - $20/mo vs $29-159/mo for Sellfy
- No revenue caps - sell unlimited without forced upgrades
- 0% platform fees on all revenue, no overage charges
- Direct Stripe payments - money goes to YOUR account
- Custom domains included on all plans
- Simpler pricing - one plan, no tiers to worry about
All Sellfy Alternatives Compared
We've analyzed the top platforms to help you find the best fit for your digital product business.
PengDrop
The #1 Sellfy Alternative for Digital Creators
Start free (5% fees) or pay $89/year for 0% vs Sellfy's $348-1,908/year
Key Features:
- Free plan with 5% commission
- $89/year for 0% commission forever
- Save vs Sellfy's $29-159/month plans
- No revenue caps or overage fees
- Instant digital delivery
- Built-in analytics dashboard
Pros:
- Lowest cost for 0% fees ($89/year)
- Free plan available (5% commission)
- Keep 100% of revenue on annual plan
- No hidden costs or surprises
Cons:
- Newer platform (rapidly growing)
- No print-on-demand (digital focused)
Best for: Digital creators who want maximum profit and complete control over their revenue
Gumroad
Popular creator platform with discovery
Key Features:
- Built-in creator marketplace
- Email marketing tools
- Audience discovery features
- Membership support
- Pre-launch pages
- Established community
Pros:
- Large creator community
- Discovery marketplace
- Strong brand recognition
- Good for audience building
Cons:
- Less customization than Sellfy
- No print-on-demand
- Limited store themes
Best for: Creators who want built-in audience discovery and community
Payhip
Free plan with built-in marketing
Key Features:
- Free plan available
- Built-in email marketing
- Affiliate program included
- EU VAT handling
- Memberships & subscriptions
- Coupons and discounts
Pros:
- Free tier with good features
- Strong marketing tools
- Good for digital products
- Established platform
Cons:
- 5% fees on free plan
- Pro plan is $99/mo for 0% fees
- Interface feels dated
Best for: Creators who want built-in marketing tools and a free starting point
Lemon Squeezy
Merchant of record with tax handling
Key Features:
- Handles global taxes & VAT automatically
- Merchant of record (they handle compliance)
- Sleek, modern design
- Subscription billing
- License key generation
- Fraud protection included
Pros:
- Tax compliance handled for you
- Beautiful checkout experience
- Good for SaaS products
- No monthly fee
Cons:
- 5% + 50¢ per transaction adds up
- Less customization options
- No physical products
Best for: Software sellers who want automatic tax compliance
Podia
All-in-one for courses & memberships
Key Features:
- Course hosting with full LMS
- Community features
- Webinar hosting
- Email marketing
- Membership sites
- Coaching products
Pros:
- 0% transaction fees
- Great for course creators
- Community building tools
- Professional course player
Cons:
- Expensive starting point ($39/mo)
- No print-on-demand
- Overkill for simple downloads
Best for: Course creators and coaches building membership communities
SendOwl
Flexible with powerful automation
Key Features:
- Powerful affiliate program
- Drip content delivery
- PDF stamping (anti-piracy)
- Cart abandonment emails
- Subscription support
- Flexible integrations
Pros:
- Strong automation features
- Great affiliate system
- Per-order pricing model
- Good for high-volume sellers
Cons:
- Dated interface
- Steeper learning curve
- Per-order fees add up
Best for: Advanced sellers who need affiliate programs and automation
Shopify
Full ecommerce powerhouse
Key Features:
- Massive app ecosystem
- Physical + digital products
- Enterprise-grade features
- Global commerce
- POS integration
- Advanced analytics
Pros:
- Industry leading platform
- Extremely scalable
- Thousands of integrations
- Full POD via apps
Cons:
- Expensive for digital-only sellers
- Complex for simple stores
- Transaction fees on top of monthly
Best for: Large businesses with complex needs and physical inventory
Feature Comparison: Sellfy vs Alternatives
See how the top platforms stack up against Sellfy
| Feature | PengDrop | Sellfy | Gumroad | Payhip | Lemon Squeezy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0% Platform Fees Available | Paid only | ||||
| Monthly Cost (0% fees) | $15/mo (annual) or $20/mo | $29-159/mo | $10/mo | $99/mo | N/A (always 5%) |
| Free Plan | |||||
| Custom Domain | Paid only | Paid only | |||
| Direct Payments (Your Stripe) | |||||
| Print on Demand | |||||
| Email Marketing | Coming soon |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why switch from Sellfy?
The main reasons creators switch from Sellfy are the high monthly costs ($29-159/month), revenue caps that force upgrades, and paying for bundled features like print-on-demand that they don't use. If you only sell digital products, you can find simpler, more affordable platforms like PengDrop that focus on what you actually need.
What is the best Sellfy alternative in 2026?
For digital product creators, PengDrop is the best Sellfy alternative because it offers 0% platform fees for just $15/month (annual) or $20/month - significantly cheaper than Sellfy's $29-159/month plans. You get unlimited revenue without caps, direct Stripe payments, and all essential features without paying for print-on-demand you might not need.
Which platform has the lowest fees?
For 0% platform fees, PengDrop ($15-20/month) is the most affordable option for digital creators. Sellfy offers 0% fees but starts at $29/month and can go up to $159/month with revenue caps. Lemon Squeezy has no monthly fee but charges 5% + 50¢ per transaction, which adds up quickly for active sellers.
Can I migrate from Sellfy to another platform?
Yes! You can export your digital products and customer data from Sellfy and import them to your new platform. PengDrop offers free migration assistance to help you transfer your digital products and get set up quickly. Most creators complete their migration in under an hour.
What if I need print-on-demand?
If print-on-demand is essential to your business, Sellfy remains a solid choice. However, you could also consider using a dedicated POD service like Printful or Printify alongside a digital platform like PengDrop - this often gives you more flexibility and potentially lower costs than Sellfy's all-in-one approach.
Are there any hidden fees with Sellfy alternatives?
With PengDrop, there are no hidden fees - just the monthly subscription and standard Stripe payment processing (2.9% + 30¢). Unlike Sellfy, there are no revenue caps or overage fees. Platforms like Lemon Squeezy have a 5% + 50¢ per-transaction fee, which is transparent but can add up with higher sales volume.